What’s the Difference Between SUP and Paddleboarding?
The watersport world has witnessed an evolution in recent years, with new variations and disciplines arising as technology and equipment improve. Among these, SUP and paddleboarding are terms that often cause confusion, as they are sometimes used interchangeably, yet they refer to different activities. While they share common elements, the fundamental differences in their approach, equipment, history, and the experience they provide distinguish them clearly.
Here we explore the nuanced differences between SUP (stand-up paddleboarding) and traditional paddleboarding, providing insight into their origins, how they are practiced, and what makes them unique within the watersport community.
1. The Basics: Defining SUP and Paddleboarding
To understand the difference between SUP and paddleboarding, it’s essential first to define what each entails.
SUP (Stand-Up Paddleboarding)
SUP, which stands for stand-up paddleboarding, is a relatively new sport that has grown exponentially in popularity over the past two decades. In SUP, the rider stands on a large, stable board (similar in appearance to a surfboard but generally wider and thicker) and uses a long paddle to propel themselves through the water.
The rider maintains an upright position for most of the activity, using the paddle to navigate, build momentum, and steer. SUP is versatile in that it can be performed in calm lakes, rivers, and open ocean waters. In fact, SUP has various offshoots, including SUP surfing, SUP yoga, racing, and even touring.
Traditional Paddleboarding
Traditional paddleboarding, also known as prone paddleboarding, predates SUP by many decades. Unlike SUP, paddleboarding involves either kneeling or lying flat on a paddleboard, and the rider propels themselves by paddling with their hands instead of using a paddle. This method is more similar to swimming and demands more from the arms and upper body.
Paddleboarding has long been a staple of ocean sports and lifeguarding communities. The boards used in traditional paddleboarding are generally more streamlined and narrow compared to SUP boards, and the activity often requires greater physical exertion, particularly in open or choppy waters.
2. A Brief History of Both Sports
To fully appreciate the differences between SUP and traditional paddleboarding, it’s important to explore their distinct histories.
The History of SUP
Stand-up paddleboarding, as we know it today, has its roots in Hawaii. Although there are records of ancient Polynesians paddling while standing on logs, modern SUP originated with Hawaiian surf instructors in the 1940s and 50s. Surf instructors like Duke Kahanamoku and John “Pop” Ah Choy would stand on their boards to get a better vantage point to watch surfers, using a paddle to maneuver themselves.
However, it wasn’t until the early 2000s that SUP gained widespread popularity, largely thanks to the efforts of surfers like Laird Hamilton, who began to use SUP as a way to cross-train for big wave surfing. Over time, SUP boards became more refined and specialised, allowing it to grow into the global phenomenon that it is today, offering different branches for recreational paddlers, fitness enthusiasts, and competitive athletes alike.
The History of Traditional Paddleboarding
Traditional paddleboarding has a longer history, with a more utilitarian beginning. It can be traced back to the early 20th century and is closely linked with the lifeguarding community. In Southern California, lifeguards would use prone paddleboards to rescue swimmers in distress because they were more effective in turbulent surf than a regular rescue board.
By the 1930s, paddleboarding had developed into a sport of its own, with enthusiasts using it for both recreation and competition. Paddleboarding races became more common, and as the decades progressed, the sport became synonymous with ocean racing and lifeguard endurance events, particularly in areas like Hawaii, Australia, and California.
3. Equipment Differences
The equipment used in SUP and paddleboarding is another major point of distinction. Each sport requires different boards and accessories, which have been specially designed to accommodate the movement and techniques involved.
SUP Equipment
- The Board: A stand-up paddleboard is larger, wider, and generally more buoyant than a traditional paddleboard. It ranges between 9 and 12 feet in length and is designed to support a standing rider. SUP boards are made with various materials, including fibreglass, epoxy, and inflatables, with the latter being particularly popular due to its portability.
- The Paddle: The most obvious difference in SUP is the use of a long paddle, which typically measures between 6 to 8 feet. The paddle has a blade at one end and a handle at the other, and it is used to push against the water to move the board forward. SUP paddles are usually made from carbon fibre, fibreglass, or aluminium.
- Leash: A leash is often used in SUP, connecting the rider to the board. This helps prevent the board from floating away in case the rider falls off in the water, especially in rough conditions.
Paddleboarding Equipment
- The Board: Traditional paddleboards are longer and narrower than SUP boards, typically between 12 to 19 feet long, making them more hydrodynamic. These boards are designed for either prone (lying flat) or kneeling positions and require a high level of balance and core strength. They are often made of lightweight materials like carbon fibre or fibreglass, optimised for speed in races or long-distance paddling.
- No Paddle: Traditional paddleboarding doesn’t involve a paddle; instead, the paddler uses their arms to propel themselves through the water. This makes the sport physically demanding, requiring strong shoulders, arms, and back muscles.
4. Technique and Physical Demands
SUP and paddleboarding require different techniques and use distinct muscle groups. Although both activities provide a full-body workout, they differ in intensity and focus.
SUP Technique
In SUP, the rider stands upright, holding the paddle with both hands and using a sweeping motion through the water to create forward momentum. A key aspect of this technique is maintaining balance while standing, which engages the core and lower body muscles. Paddlers can alternate between sides to steer the board, creating a rhythmic flow.
While SUP can be a demanding workout, especially in high winds or strong currents, it is also an activity that beginners can easily learn. Since the board is generally large and stable, SUP allows for a gentler learning curve, making it popular for recreational use and for people of all ages and fitness levels.
Paddleboarding Technique
Traditional paddleboarding involves a prone or kneeling position. Riders alternate between paddling with their arms in front of the body in a crawl-like motion. The technique shares similarities with swimming, with each stroke requiring a coordinated movement of the arms, shoulders, and upper back.
This arm-powered paddling is far more strenuous than SUP, making it a more demanding cardiovascular and strength workout. Prone paddleboarding especially works the shoulders, chest, and triceps, along with the back muscles. As paddlers can lie flat on their boards, traditional paddleboarding is well-suited to long-distance endurance races.
5. Accessibility and Skill Levels
SUP Accessibility
One of the reasons why SUP has become so popular worldwide is its accessibility. Because the equipment is more stable, learning to SUP is relatively easy for beginners. Many people can pick up basic paddling techniques within an hour or two of instruction, making it a family-friendly and beginner-friendly watersport.
SUP is versatile and adaptable to different water environments, from calm lakes to more challenging ocean surf. For those who want to take it further, there are competitive racing circuits, as well as SUP surfing and SUP yoga, allowing for a range of experiences depending on the paddler’s interest and skill level.
Paddleboarding Accessibility
Traditional paddleboarding, on the other hand, is considered more physically demanding and has a steeper learning curve. The required prone or kneeling position can be uncomfortable for long periods, especially for those unaccustomed to the movement.
This watersport is more niche, attracting those who are already athletically inclined or who want to focus on endurance paddling. It is also less commonly seen in beginner-friendly environments like calm lakes, as it is often practiced in oceanic conditions or for long-distance races.
6. Competitive Elements and Communities
Both SUP and traditional paddleboarding have established competitive scenes, but they differ in scale and global recognition.
SUP Competitions
SUP competitions have taken off globally, with events ranging from casual races to high-level international championships. There are different categories of SUP racing, including distance races, sprint races, and technical races that involve navigating buoys or obstacles. SUP surfing competitions also offer a unique hybrid between traditional surfing and SUP.
Paddleboarding Competitions
Traditional paddleboarding races are well-established in coastal regions with lifeguard and ocean sports traditions. Events like the Molokai to Oahu Paddleboard World Championships in Hawaii are considered the pinnacle of prone paddleboarding, attracting elite athletes from around the world. These races often cover long distances and require a high level of endurance.
Conclusion
While SUP and paddleboarding share the same overarching concept of using a board to traverse the water, they are distinct sports with different origins, equipment, techniques, and physical demands. SUP, with its standing position and use of a paddle, has broad appeal, offering accessibility for beginners and a wide range of applications for seasoned paddlers. Traditional paddleboarding, with its prone or kneeling position and focus on arm propulsion, demands greater physical endurance and is more specialised, appealing to those seeking a full-body challenge.
Ultimately, the choice between SUP and traditional paddleboarding comes down to personal preference, physical fitness level, and the type of experience you seek on the water. Whether you’re looking for a leisurely paddle across a calm lake or an endurance challenge on the ocean, there’s a watersport waiting for you in these two fascinating disciplines.
For more information on Paddleboarding Sessions contact Herts Young Mariners Base.
See all our Paddleboarding Courses at Herts Young Mariners Base.